ecomii - a better way
February 09, 2010  |  Login
Green Roofs: Determining if a Green Roof is Right for Your Home
By Eric Corey Freed
 
Email This Article
  Share This Article
  Del.icio.us
  Digg
  Facebook
  Reddit
Cleaning Your Water

A green roof is not a roof with green-colored shingles — it’s a supplemental roofing system made up of plant material that’s applied over a conventional roof. Think of the green roof as an extension of the existing roof.

The Pros of Green Roofs

Green roofs offer numerous benefits, including the following:

  • Insulation: Because of their earthen mass, a green roof adds a lot of insulation to the roof, which saves you money on your energy bills.
  • Environmental factors: The plants on the roof can be used to filter and clean water, while automatically absorbing pollution and giving off oxygen for you to breathe.
  • Protection: Because a green roof sits over your roof membrane, it protects the roof from damage.
  • Appearance: A roof is typically the least attractive part of any building, but a green roof is a beautiful replacement.
  • Cool temperatures: Plants keep your roof cool, reducing the ambient temperature around a building (called a heat island).
  • Value: The preceding benefits add to the value of your home.

The Drawbacks of Green Roofs

Potential concerns and drawbacks including the following:

  • Uncertainty about long-term performance: Green roofs are still considered a new technology in North America — too new to have a track record. Even in Europe, where green roofs have been around for over 25 years, experts are only beginning to gather information on long-term performance. The biggest concern with any roof is leaking. Because a green roof adds an additional layer of protection, you can at least expect a longer life from the conventional roof.
  • Cost: Because a green roof is used in addition to, not instead of, a conventional roof, it costs more. As a general rule, you can expect an installed extensive green roof with waterproof membranes and irrigation to cost about $12 to $24 per square foot. This may sound expensive, but keep in mind that a green roof extends the life of the roof membrane and will reduce the heating and cooling costs of your home. Although an extensive green roof may cost $12 to $24 per square foot, less expensive alternatives are available. Green grid systems,available from companies such as GreenGrid, consist of plastic trays that snap together into a grid. Priced at around $8 per square foot, these systems are a great alternative for existing buildings where an extensive green roof is not possible. These modular systems don’t provide the same amount of insulation, roof protection, or flexibility in planting as a full green roof system, however.
  • Difficulty of repairs: Although a green roof covers and protects the conventional roof below, finding leaks and fixing repairs is much more difficult. You have to remove the vegetation, soil, and drainage in order to inspect the roof for leaks. Modular grid systems make this process much easier because they can be removed in pieces.
  • Competition with other green functions of a roof: In a green building, roof space is valuable. A green roof competes for space with solar panels and rainwater harvesting. By limiting the green roof to areas that are much more visible (because they’re so beautiful), and locating the solar panels in areas more hidden (because they aren’t as attractive), you can keep your roof attractive and functional.
Remember: Most new ideas in the building industry face significant hurdles, and that’s certainly the case with green roofs. You may have some initial concerns about a green roof in terms of leaking, weight, or maintenance, but the benefits far outweigh these, especially when you consider the money saved in heating and cooling costs over the life of the building.


Determining Whether a Green Roof is Right for You

A green roof is a wonderfully simple and effective way to add value, beauty, and green features to a building. But when you’re thinking about adding a green roof to an existing house, be sure to ask yourself the following questions:
  • Is the roof slope too steep for plants? Flat and low-slope roofs are easier for the plants to fix into the soil. A low-slope roof is any roof you could walk up without leaning forward.  ....read more
 
 

Recent Message Board Posts

 

 
 
ecomii featured poll

Are vitamins and supplements effective?

 

 

Are vitamins and supplements effective?
 
the ecomii eight
1 Winter Squash   5 Pistachio Stuffing
2 Chestnuts   6 Cap & Trade
3 Carbon Footprint   7 Pecan Pie
4 Supplements   8 Natural Health
 
ecomii resources
 
ecomii Tips Newsletter 

Sign up today to receive a weekly tip for living greener

 
Get in Touch

Got suggestions? Want to write for us? See something we could improve? Let us know!